Is it really necessary to compartmentalize our life?

IS IT REALLY NECESSARY to compartmentalize our life? I asked this question when I was reading an article in the Guardian newspaper, saying that X (Twitter) has been taken over by the right wing. It wasn’t, but it made me to question the following: why is it that we have to put everything into precise boxes? Right wing versus left wing, Christianity versus the rest, being pro-Brexit versus anti-Brexit, etc.

I have been asking this question for a while as I struggle to attach labels to my own life, political views, belief systems and eating preferences. Take Brexit as an example: I was definitely against the UK leaving the EU, but while I was extremely disappointed in the beginning, I also understood eventually as to why people voted to leave the EU. I am living in the EU now, and I struggle to understand their policies. I really like the EU as a force for good, but realistically speaking, it has become a huge bureaucratic machine where the view of an ordinary person doesn’t matter anymore. Everything is decided in Brussels, with most European Union’s employees not really caring or understanding the ordinary folk. I lived in Brussels, I saw it with my proper eyes. You spend most days on long lunches with friends, and party in the evening in Jeux d’Hiver, a nice club, no doubt, but very much detached from the daily reality of people whom the EU is supposed to serve.

Therefore, I am both pro-EU and against EU’s bureaucracy – what does it make me? A right wing? Left wing? Or something in the middle?

Twitter (X) wasn’t taken by the right wing, because I see on my own feed page both views of the debate (left and right), and if anything it makes me laugh. How it possible, I wonder, to be able to assign a definite political label on someone? I am very pro strong family unit, I believe in God, and I don’t agree that something meaningful can be achieved when protesters (for whatever reason) glue themselves to the road. Does it make me right wing?

But I am also pro-diversity, definitely pro LGBT rights, and democracy – does it make me left wing?

I have no idea!

I am also a Christian, and I believe in God, but nothing can stop me from doing Tarot cards because I also believe in something that is beyond a particular set of dogma. Does it make me a witch? Am I failed Christian? Or I can remain being a Christian despite my Tarot cards and taking moon phases seriously?

I wonder.

The same goes to my eating preferences. I made several attempts to become a vegetarian, but it didn’t last, simply because my son needs proteins and I don’t have enough energy to make us two separate meals. What does it make me? A failed vegetarian or an occasional vegetarian, or a hypocrite when it comes to food?

And thus, I balance in my life between different views and opinions, simply because I don’t think that putting a precise box on someone, is a way to go, there should be something in the middle, something flexible, and leaving the room to a person to change his/her mind in regards to political views, belief system, and eating preferences.

What do you think?



6 responses to “Is it really necessary to compartmentalize our life?”

  1. When I reflect on my life (as a timeline) the labels mount and fall away. Too many to list.

    People form their labels. These do not always match ones I put upon myself.

    At times I hear “I didn’t think you were like that” + “I thought I knew you” + “You like that? I’m surprised…(insert their thought-stream here)” + “I thought you were my friend” – again too many to list right now. Or the big one, “What do you think” – which often opens the flood gates of an unwanted Q and A session.

    So I’m confused, thinking that maybe I am not myself at times. I don’t fight it. Perhaps I had a bad meal, a headache, some sickness, some limit I passed that made my behavior noticeable to those in that time and place. A few days later all is forgotten/forgiven.

    So, I think compartments are unavoidable but not necessary.

    “That’s life” + “Think out of the box” + “Oh no, Mike has fallen into the well of idioms again, throw him a rope? No he is just nuts, leave him alone. He never listens to us anyway”

    1. Ha ha ha! Yes, we also change our minds about certain issues. It isn’t set in stone, but many don’t realise how easy it is to change a political opinion, beliefs etc

      1. I like revisiting this topic (it showed up in my feed today on another social media platform) – it reminds me when I clean/sort my office and find things I wrote many years before that seem to be written by someone else! There are some terms for this. In the past I have mentioned it to others who have similar happenings in their lives. We evolve? Words fail me again. Take care as always!

      2. Yes, we change our minds, don’t we? And constantly evolve. But somehow the society imposes on us purely dogmatic way of thinking! Be that or that, and if you are not that, you aren’t part of us

  2. There are “compartments” that are useful in thinking about life, like animals, plants, etc. But there are others that are basically superficial and just used to divide us. The general public does not tend to distinguish between the two, while the media tends to push the superficial ones, as they are interested in maintaining a level of confusion and upset among us.

    In the end, each of us must decide which compartments are useful and which are not. It is a learning process that more of us need to go through. We also have certain universal truths that unite us and we should not forget them. Those who want to keep us divided are trying to hide those universal truths from us. So it is also up to each of us to learn what they are.

    1. So true! There are universal truths that unite us and you are right that mainstream media tries to polarise us all the time!

Leave a Reply to lecoxCancel reply

About Me

I am a doctor of philosophy, a university lecturer, and a lover of cats, fine wine, dancing, theatre, and human eccentricity. I was born in the Soviet Union (Moscow). I am fluent in four languages, and have spent all my adult life studying (except from 18 to 19) working and living throughout Western Europe. Despite a surname-Netchitailova- that translates from Russian into English as “unreadable”, my greatest passions in life are reading and writing. My personal struggles have made me appreciate the manifestations of weirdness that exist everywhere.

Newsletter

Discover more from Ekaterina Netchitailova

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading